The Problem:
In Swift Tasks, why doesn’t the code print "cancelled" when a task is cancelled using task.cancel()
? Is there a better way to check for task cancellation?
The Solutions:
Solution 1: Use non-blocking `Task.sleep` or move `test` off the main actor
Problem:
In the given code, the test
function is blocking the main actor by running in a tight loop without any suspension points (i.e., no await
). This prevents the task.cancel()
line from being reached, resulting in the cancellation check never being performed.
Solution:
There are two ways to address this issue:
-
Move
test
off the main actor:By marking
test
asnonisolated
, it will no longer run on the main actor and will not block it. However, it’s important to note that blocking any thread in the Swift concurrency cooperative thread pool is generally discouraged. -
Use non-blocking
Task.sleep
:Instead of the tightly spinning loop, use
Task.sleep
with a short duration (e.g., 0.5 seconds) to introduce a suspension point. This allows the main actor to make progress and eventually execute thetask.cancel()
line.
Additional Considerations:
- If
test
is a time-consuming spinning process, it should be moved off the main actor, periodically calltry Task.checkCancellation()
, and also periodically calltry Task.yield()
. - For legacy cancelable API, consider using
withTaskCancellationHandler
to proactively stop the asynchronous process when a task is canceled. - Generally, relying on
Task.isCancelled
and manually throwingCancellationError
is the most cumbersome approach, but it works.
Q&A
Why the following code doesn’t print "cancelled". Am I checking task cancellation in a wrong way?
The main actor is isolated and blocked by your while loop, so the task is never cancelled.
How can i fix the cancelation tasks in the given code
Use withTaskCancellationHandler
to wrap your cancelable asynchronous process or use try Task.checkCancellation()
within a loop.
What’s the most effective approch to check if the current task is cancelled?
If you are using async throws
functions, most of them already support cancellation. Use that.
Video Explanation:
The following video, titled "How to Add Local Push Notifications to Your iOS App with Swift ...", provides additional insights and in-depth exploration related to the topics discussed in this post.
This video provides further insights and detailed explanations related to the content discussed in the article.
The following video, titled "How to Add Local Push Notifications to Your iOS App with Swift ...", provides additional insights and in-depth exploration related to the topics discussed in this post.
This video provides further insights and detailed explanations related to the content discussed in the article.